On Repentance
Last time, I mentioned Mike Guglielmucci’s big lie. Our pastor made a great point about it this week, though. It’s so easy for us to condemn those who sin in big ways like this, especially when we ourselves never have. The thing is, it is not our place to condemn. It is certainly our job to point out sin and call for repentance, and as a church I think we’re really good at that. What we’re not any good at is accepting those who repent after something like this. We don’t know how forgive someone we can no longer trust, but Jesus didn’t give us any options to not forgive.
Lest we think there might be exceptions for extreme cases, look at King David – a supreme pillar of faith, mentioned as such throughout the Bible, beginning to end. Yet the man lusted after another man’s wife, abused his position as king to sleep with her, lied to her husband, and then killed him when he was too upright to accept the lie. That’s not the only thing he did, but it’s easily among the worst – not to mention worse than what most of us, or our modern fallen priests and pastors, have ever done.
God punished him for it, yet he also used it for good. He didn’t kill David or Bathsheba. He didn’t remove David from kingship or the blessing of the Messiah via his lineage. He even allowed Bathsheba’s second son to become, not just the next king, but the richest and wisest king who ever lived. If that doesn’t say that God still loves the guy, then I don’t know what does.
And that’s the problem – we don’t love. We’re really good at rules and rewards and punishments and marketing and manipulating and judging and condemning, but we suck at forgiveness. In order to forgive someone, you have to love them. In my own struggles with this, I’ve learned that it is possible to love someone you don’t completely trust. In this job, I have to punish-yet-love every single day. If I don’t love, then the punishments only serve to drive my kids further away – they do more harm than good. At the same time I know better than to leave money lying around, you know?
So with Mike G, and other pastors like him who have made big mistakes, we need to give them room for repentance and, when they do, forgive and love as if nothing happened to breach the relationship.
Though I would ask for a second opinion if he says he’s dying again.



